The Act violates the fundamental American ideal of “checks and balances” on government power.
Normally, the government can not conduct a search of a citizen’s residence without obtaining a warrant and demonstrating a reason to believe that the suspect has committed (or may commit) a crime.
But the Patriot Act violates the Fourth Amendment by allowing the government to conduct searches without a warrant—for just about any reason.
If the FBI is ever questioned about such activity, shrewd FBI officials simply state that the investigation is crucial to national security, and they are permitted to continue with the operation.
An overwhelming sense of national unity overtook the country and Americans united to face the newly discovered threat of terrorism in a modern age.
Compels Us Act Essay Essay Of Civil Disobedience
The President’s approval rating increased from 54% to 86%—its highest level ever—in a matter of days (Ruggles).The American people rallied behind the Federal government and provided support.Tragically, Congress drafted the Patriot Act and decreed that it would be the solution to America’s problems.According to Congress, the Patriot Act would protect America from its enemies who operated on American soil. the climate of fear in the weeks after the September 11 attacks and the haste with which the Patriot Act was passed allowed some of its more controversial aspects to escape adequate congressional scrutiny.” Clearly, the “fear frenzy” that took place after the September 11 attacks caused Americans to sacrifice essential civil rights in exchange for a sense of security.Many Americans unquestionably accepted the Act to avoid the risk of being labeled “unpatriotic.” However, thousands of far-seeing Americans publicly questioned the actions of the government, but their cries were not heard. The only Senator to vote against the Patriot Act was Senator Feingold.When the House of Representatives sent the Patriot Act to the Senate, it passed with a vote of 96-1. Feingold is significant because he was the only Senator to fight against the Patriot Act before it was signed into law.The arguments that he made against the Act during September and October of 2001 continue to point out the negative effects the Act has had on American life and will continue to have moving forward in the twenty-first century.Many of the Patriot Act’s provisions are in clear violation of the U. Constitution—a document drafted by wise men like Benjamin Franklin, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and George Washington in order to protect American rights and freedoms.The Patriot Act encroaches on sacred First Amendment rights, which protect free speech and expression, and Fourth Amendment rights, which protect citizens against “unwarranted search and seizure” (Justice).In more recent years the situation has improved somewhat, however.Now, before conducting a search, the FBI must obtain a warrant from a secret Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISA).